Comparing Mortgage Scenarios: What to Look For
In this article
Beyond the Headline Rate
When a bank shows you a mortgage offer, the interest rate is the biggest number on the page. But two mortgages with identical rates can cost thousands more or less depending on the term, fees, flexibility, and repayment type. Here's how to compare properly.
The Most Important Number: Total Repayable
The single most useful figure when comparing mortgages is the total amount repayable — every euro you'll ever pay back including interest, principal, and fees. Lenders are required to show this in their standardised information sheet (Europees Gestandaardiseerd Informatieblad, ESIS).
Loan: €300,000 @ 4.5% (annuity)
25-year term: Monthly €1,668 → Total paid: €500,200
30-year term: Monthly €1,520 → Total paid: €547,200
The 30-year mortgage saves about €148/month but costs €47,000 more overall.
APR vs Headline Rate
The Annual Percentage Rate (APR, in Dutch: jaarlijks kostenpercentage or JKP) includes the costs you pay to get the loan — such as arrangement and valuation costs — spread over the term. It's a fairer comparison than the headline rate alone.
Bank A: 3.9% rate + €2,500 one-off costs
Bank B: 4.1% rate, no one-off costs
After 3 years, Bank A has cost you roughly €700 more, despite the lower headline rate. After 10 years, Bank A is about €3,200 cheaper, because the one-off costs are spread over more years.
The Loan Term Effect
Longer terms mean lower monthly payments but dramatically more interest. Extending from 25 to 30 years might feel affordable but carries a significant hidden cost.
| Term | Monthly | Total Interest | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 years | €1,898 | €155,500 | — |
| 25 years | €1,668 | €200,200 | +€44,700 |
| 30 years | €1,520 | €247,200 | +€91,700 |
(All based on a €300,000 annuity mortgage @ 4.5%)
Annuity vs Linear — The Hidden Difference
Comparing two offers of the same rate and term but different repayment type:
Annuity: Month 1 payment €1,520 — same every month — total interest: €247,200
Linear: Month 1 payment €1,958, Month 360 payment €836 — total interest: €203,100
Linear saves €44,100 in total interest. But the first payment is €438 higher.
When comparing scenarios, always make sure you're comparing the same repayment type — or use our calculator to compare all combinations.
Flexibility Features
Rate and cost aren't everything. Consider what happens if your life changes:
- Overpayment allowance: How much can you repay extra each year without a penalty (boeterente)? Most Dutch lenders allow at least 10% of the original loan per year.
- Portability: Can you take the mortgage and its rate to a new property? (Important if you may move)
- Payment holiday: Can you pause payments in hardship? This differs per lender, so check the terms.
- End of the fixed-rate period: What happens when your fixed-rate period ends? Your lender then offers you a new rate, and that rate can be higher than what you could get elsewhere at that moment.
Scenario Comparison Example
| Scenario | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | €300,000 | €300,000 | €300,000 |
| Rate | 3.5% | 4.5% | 5.0% |
| Term | 30 yr | 20 yr | 15 yr |
| Type | Annuity | Annuity | Linear |
| First payment | €1,347 | €1,898 | €2,917 |
| Total interest | €185,000 | €155,500 | €113,100 |
| Total cost | €485,000 | €455,500 | €413,100 |
Scenario A has the lowest rate and the lowest monthly payment, but costs €71,900 more than Scenario C over its lifetime — mainly because of the longer term.
The rates in this article are examples, not today's rates. You'll find current rates on our Interest Rates page.
Open Scenario Comparison →